Anxiety
Disorders and Alcohol Abuse
For
some people, a glass of wine after a long day
at work is used to help "take the edge
off," or a drink at a party to help "loosen
up." For many of these individuals, alcohol
use in moderation is not of concern. However,
for people with anxiety disorders, using alcohol
or other substances can make anxiety symptoms
worse and can even trigger panic attacks. Moreover,
the risk and occurrence of alcohol abuse is
high in people with anxiety disorders. This
makes alcohol use an important issue to consider
for people with anxiety disorders.
According
to a major study released in 2004 on co-occurring
alcohol abuse and mental health disorders (called
the National Epidemiologic Survey on Alcohol
and Related Conditions and conducted by
the National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and
Alcoholism), about 20 percent of Americans with
a current anxiety or mood disorder (such as
depression) also have a current alcohol or other
substance abuse disorder, and about 20 percent
of those with a current alcohol/substance abuse
disorder also have a current anxiety or mood
disorder. Other studies have put these numbers
even higher. While having co-occurring alcohol
abuse and anxiety disorders can make an individual's
situation more complex, the good news is that
these disorders are treatable - separately and
together. Read on to learn more about the co-occurrence
of anxiety disorders and alcohol abuse, and
how they can be treated.
Are
people with anxiety disorders more likely to
suffer from alcohol abuse than the general population
and vice versa?
People
with anxiety disorders are two to three times
more likely to have an alcohol or other substance
abuse disorder at some point in their lives
than the general population, and vice versa.
However, as explained in more detail later in
this piece, the risk and prevalence of alcohol
abuse is more common among people with certain
anxiety disorders than others.
Which
occurs first in people with co-occurring disorders
- the anxiety disorder or alcohol abuse?
There
is a lot of variability in how people experience
these conditions together. Possible courses
of the co-occurring conditions include:
- The
alcohol abuse and anxiety disorders are independent
of one another, meaning that one does not
cause the development of the other. However,
the symptoms of one can make the symptoms
of the other worse.
-
An anxiety disorder leads an individual to
use alcohol or other substances to "self-medicate,"
or attempt to alleviate their anxiety symptoms
on their own (which does not help, and only
exacerbates, their anxiety).
- An
alcohol abuse problem causes heightened anxiety
during certain specific periods of abuse,
such as during the actual time of drinking
and/or withdrawal states (some studies have
shown the withdrawal from alcohol may activate
the same neural pathways as anxiety). These
anxiety symptoms may go away during other
times and usually are eliminated completely
after the problem drinking stops.
-
An alcohol or other substance abuse problem
leads to development of a substance-induced
anxiety disorder in which a person's substance
abuse causes anxiety to exist all or close
to all the time during a period of alcohol
or other substance abuse in one's life. This
may happen because some substances change
the way brain cells communicate with each
other, including affecting the amount of neurotransmitters
(or chemical messengers) in an individual's
nervous system. Thus, substance abuse can
damage parts of the brain that keep anxiety
in check. This type of anxiety disorder will
last during the period of substance abuse,
and sometimes for a short period of time after
the substance abuse has stopped.
In
the past, there was a general consensus that
among people who abuse alcohol, those who also
had an anxiety and/or mood disorder were usually
substance-induced and the disorder would disappear
once the substance abuse was treated. However,
according to the earlier-mentioned National
Epidemiologic Survey on Alcohol and Related
Conditions, the vast majority of people
with both alcohol/substance abuse and anxiety
disorders experience them independently, with
none or only some of anxiety episodes being
induced by alcohol or drugs. This is important
point for both patients and therapists, who
should not assume that treating substance abuse
will solve an anxiety disorder on its own. Treating
both disorders together is often necessary.
What
added difficulties can arise from having both
alcohol abuse and anxiety disorders?
Having
both an anxiety disorder and alcohol abuse disorder
can have a "vicious cycle" effect.
For example, someone with an anxiety disorder
may use alcohol to alleviate their anxiety symptoms,
causing them to experience more anxiety as a
side effect of using these substances, which
then leads them to drink more alcohol. Other
complications may include:
- People
with the co-occurring disorders are at high
risk for many additional problems such as
hospitalizations, financial problems, family
problems and medical illnesses.
-
People with both disorders may have lower
treatment compliance than people with just
one disorder.
-
People with both an anxiety disorder and alcohol
abuse have an increased risk of relapse into
alcohol abuse than people who have an alcohol
problem without anxiety.
-
People with both disorders may be at an increased
risk for experiencing dangerous interactions
between prescription medication and alcohol
(in the event that they relapse into alcohol
abuse) than people with an anxiety disorder
alone.
- People
with an anxiety disorder may have more pronounced
alcohol withdrawal symptoms than alcohol abusers
without anxiety.
This
makes it of the utmost importance to treat both
disorders. The above points should all be discussed
with a doctor when determining an individual
treatment plan.
Are
there specific anxiety disorders that are more
often associated with alcohol abuse? How does
the relationship between anxiety and alcohol
differ based on a person's specific anxiety
disorder?
While
individuals with any anxiety disorder can also
have an alcohol abuse problem, research has
found this co-occurrence is more common in people
with certain anxiety disorders, including social
anxiety disorder (SAD) and posttraumatic
stress disorder (PTSD). Moreover, some research
has shown the order in which the disorders develop
often varies based on the type of anxiety disorder
(although, as noted earlier, any order of development
is possible as every person is different). For
example, alcohol abuse in people with SAD and
agoraphobia usually develops after the onset
of the anxiety disorder (with people reporting
they are using the alcohol in an attempt to
control anxiety, i.e., "self medication").
On the other hand, alcohol abuse commonly begins
before or at the same time as anxiety
symptoms in people with generalized
anxiety disorder (GAD) and panic
disorder. Again, this is not always the
case.
Some
disorders also have noteworthy considerations/circumstances
when co-occurring with alcohol abuse. These
include:
Panic
Disorder - Panic attacks can often be caused
by use of alcohol or drugs, worsening the course
of a person's disorder (or even inducing it).
Panic disorder has also been singled out in
research as a risk factor for a major substance
abuse relapse among people with both disorders.
Posttraumatic
Stress Disorder (PTSD) - PTSD and alcohol
abuse may commonly occur together for a variety
of reasons, including alcohol abuse may increase
the likelihood of being exposed to trauma (and
thus developing PTSD), or individuals with PTSD
may use alcohol to "self medicate"
in an attempt to ease their symptoms. Many characteristics
of substance abuse can exacerbate symptoms of
PTSD, including sleep disturbance and irritability.
While professionals in the past often treated
substance abuse before treating co-occurring
PTSD, many now treat them together because symptoms
of PTSD (such as intrusive thoughts and sleep
disturbance) can drive relapse to substance
abuse.
Social
Anxiety Disorder (SAD) - Often, people with
social anxiety report that alcohol helps lessen
their social anxiety, which is likely why alcohol
abuse is so common in this population. However,
in reality, substance use often makes anxiety
worse. There are also special treatment considerations
for people with co-occurring substance abuse
and social anxiety. Certain treatment approaches
commonly used for substance abuse, such as group
therapy or 12-step programs (used by Alcoholics
Anonymous or Narcotics Anonymous) may be difficult
for a socially anxious person. Thus, a more
individualized treatment strategy may be necessary
for people with co-occurring SAD and substance
abuse.
Can
an anxiety disorder and substance abuse be treated
at the same time and by the same professional?
Many
professionals will suggest treating these conditions
at the same time to offer the best chance for
successful recovery and lessen the chance of
relapse, particularly when one disorder is not
causing the other. (For a substance-induced
anxiety disorder, the substance abuse would
be addressed first because the anxiety should
improve after abuse terminates). Many professionals
or treatment teams can treat these disorders
together. Ask your doctor if he or she can treat
both conditions by him/herself, or in conjunction
with another professional as part of a treatment
team.
What
treatments are available for people suffering
from both?
Researchers
are still exploring how to best treat people
with both conditions. Many therapists will attempt
to use non-medication treatments for people
with both anxiety and substance abuse disorders
because of the increased risk for abuse of medication
among substance users. When prescription medications
are used, therapists aim to use ones that have
low abuse potential and that are safe if taken
with abused substances should a person relapse
into alcohol or drug use. (Note that even when
considered "safe" by an interaction
standpoint, medications that treat anxiety and/or
substance abuse are less effective when used
with alcohol or drugs.) While medications that
effectively treat both anxiety disorders and
substance abuse are still being explored, many
doctors will suggest using an SSRI, a group
of antidepressants commonly used in the treatment
of anxiety disorders that include Prozac (fluoxetine),
Zoloft (sertraline), Luvox (fluvoxamine), Paxil
(paroxetine), Celexa (citalopram) and Lexapro
(escitalopram), often in conjunction with therapy.
Many doctors will avoid prescribing people with
both disorders benzodiazepines, another group
of medications also used to treat anxiety disorders,
because they can carry an increased risk of
abuse, tolerance and physical dependence and
thus may not be the best option for someone
with current or past substance abuse.
The
choice of medication should be discussed carefully
between doctor and patient and will always depend
on individual circumstances. This choice will
also depend on the specific anxiety disorder
a person suffers from (i.e., panic disorder,
obsessive-compulsive disorder, etc.), as some
medications will be more effective than others
for an individual disorder.
Other
treatment options for both anxiety disorders
and substance abuse, which can be used alone
or in combination with medication, include:
- Cognitive-behavioral
therapy (CBT) - Individuals learn to identify,
challenge and gain control over unwanted behaviors.
These therapies have been demonstrated effective
in both anxiety and substance abuse disorders.
- Individual
psychotherapy - Individuals explore areas
of emotional and social conflict. This is
used for both disorders.
- Group
psychotherapy - Individuals gather in
a group to discuss shared and individual experiences.
This is also used for both disorders.
- Self-help/other
treatment groups - Individuals with similar
needs or experiences meet, and meetings are
facilitated by a consumer, layperson or survivor.
Self-help groups for anxiety disorders can
be found on ADAA's website here.
You can also contact Alcoholics Anonymous
or Narcotics Anonymous for meetings in your
area.
For
more information on treatment options, click
here.
How
can I find help in my area?
ADAA
offers a searchable listing of mental health
professionals nationwide. Click
here to find a therapist. You can also search
for addiction professionals by state on the
NAADAC, the Association for Addiction Professionals,
website
here.
References
and Resources
About.Com:
"Anxiety Disorders Can Prompt Alcoholic
Relapse"
Alcoholics
Anonymous
Alcohol
Research & Health: "Social Anxiety
Disorder and Alcohol Use" (Vol. 26, No.
2, 2002)
American
Journal of Psychiatry: "Alcohol Use and
Anxiety: Diagnostic and Management Issues"
(164:2, February 2007)
Narcotics
Anonymous
National
Drug Intelligence Center (Department of Justice)
National
Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism
National
Institute of Mental Health
Psychiatric
Times
Substance
Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration
The
International Society for Traumatic Stress Studies
WebMD:
"Anxiety Disorders Linked with Alcoholism
Relapse"
|