Advertisement

by Bryan Balvaneda, M.A., Lizabeth Roemer, PhD., Sarah Hayes-Skelton, PhD., Amelia Yang, B.S., and Anna Ying, M.A.

Major crises raise people’s concern for personal safety and heighten anxiety. One effect of this heightened anxiety is that it can intensify bias and discrimination as we start focusing our attention on our own well-being. Throughout the COVID-19 crisis many individuals, particularly those from East Asian backgrounds, are reporting more  experiences of racism and xenophobia. We write to highlight ways to respond if you are experiencing bias and discrimination or if you are an ally who wants to support them.

East Asian individuals have been unfairly targeted for discrimination and bias partially due to the virus first being identified in Wuhan, China. The disease was initially termed the “Wuhan coronavirus,” and still referred to by some as the “Chinese virus,” terms that closely associate Chinese communities with the virus. Racialization is a process by which all individuals from a certain background are grouped together due to perceived biological characteristics. Because of racialization, anyone with an East Asian background has become associated with the virus. Moreover, using this terminology ignores the national and international political, economic, and healthcare systems that contributed to the virus becoming a pandemic and concern for all people.

Historical and present contexts place individuals from East Asian backgrounds at greater risk of discrimination. Historically, East Asian communities have been the target of health-related attacks on their culture, especially with regard to food (for further context, please see the footnote below).

Presently, Asian individuals have been unfairly targeted by being accused of having COVID-19 when expressing normal, non-illness related coughing or sneezing and when demonstrating symptoms of a common cold or seasonal flu. In addition, East Asian individuals have been more likely to experience negative consequences of showing symptoms, such as “victim blaming” and accusing the culture as the reason for the disease, experiencing racialized violence when showing symptoms, such as slurs or glares, and being removed from public spaces (e.g., asking them to leave classrooms, workplaces).

If you have been the victim of racism, some suggestions for you to cope include:

-Recognize experiences of racism are real and not you being “oversensitive” Racism is a persistent social problem, and if you feel you have been targeted by prejudice and discrimination, it is important to recognize that these are real issues that take a toll on your physical and mental wellbeing. You can also emphasize taking moments to care for yourself and others when hurt by discrimination and remember that you have the right to be seen, welcomed, supported, served, and helped.

-Recognize the strength of your communities and reject attacks on your values. Communities of color and immigrants hold many strengths, including the strengths of your cultural values and social contributions. Identify and elect to receive information sources and communities that offer accurate, sensitive information on the outbreak.

-Hold together in solidarity. Supporting one another can help your communities utilize their strengths in the face of racism. During these times, racist individuals and systems may attempt to drive your communities apart, holding some actions and communities as “better” (e.g., the “Model Minority”) while rejecting others. Find ways to connect when practicing social distancing, such as through social media groups and other virtual communities. Stand together in the fight against racism to anyone.

-Connect to resources from your community. Sharing and utilizing resources, such as the one linked here, can help you find support from others experiencing similar struggles. These psychologists offer other suggestions for communal support.

Racism is an issue we must all address, not just individuals engaging in racist acts and the victims of racism. Thus, those of us who aren’t being targeted can support those facing discrimination by:

-Calling out racist comments and acts when you see them. This can feel uncomfortable if you are not used to doing this, but saying something like, “This virus is not connected to a country or a specific group of people - calling it that puts Asian people at risk and is unnecessarily harmful” can be helpful. Online, you can provide links to accurate information, and report the comments to moderation staff.

-Interrupt racism, such as by creating distance between the person making racist comments or actions and the victim. This can look like physically or verbally distracting or blocking those using slurs, as you feel you are able to safely do so.

-Notice when you have engaged in actions that maintain discrimination and prejudice. Silence and inaction, such as not doing anything when someone uses a slur or makes a racist joke, maintains the racism by allowing unjust and discriminatory actions and systems to continue.

If you notice you have acted in a harmful way, find ways to apologize without excusing your actions (or inactions), and make personal commitments to correct the situation individually and engage in social action.

-Offer support to individuals facing discrimination and ask permission to act on their behalf. This can look like offering to speak to others about the discrimination or to write letters or report the discrimination. It can also involve listening to people expressing their pain and hurt and making sure to validate that pain and the reality and injustice of their racist experiences.

-Support Asian communities economically and socially. This includes but is not limited to donating to local community and mutual aid organizations, as well as shopping at businesses owned by Asians, especially restaurants (both now and in the future), which have been particularly vulnerable to health-related attacks. Ordering take-out from Chinese-restaurants is one concrete way to counter this injustice.

-Find ways to connect to the sense of caring and concern for others you feel now and create reminders for continuing to help later.  This may include: practicing empathy for all, educating those in your social circles, posting relevant articles on social media, remembering that it is especially important to also be caring for yourself physically and mentally, and remembering these perspectives when this immediate crisis is over.

----------------------------------------

Footnote: It’s helpful to understand the context in which this racism occurs. Disease naming has no rhyme or reason – Swine flu emerged in Mexico, Mad Cow disease in the United Kingdom, and the “Spanish flu” has been believed by researchers to not have emerged in Spain at all – the name arose out of how reports could be published during World War I. Continuing to use the “Wuhan coronavirus” or “Chinese virus” designation only serves to further bias and discrimination, and ignores the national and international political, economic, and healthcare systems that contributed to the virus becoming a pandemic and concern for all people.

Moreover, health-related attacks on Asian communities are not new. Asian communities have been historically targeted with health-related attacks, from attacks on the Asian food industry for false reports of the use of “questionable” sources of meat and the use of MSG as an “unhealthy” food additive.


About the Authors

Bryan Balvaneda is an advanced doctoral candidate at the University of Massachusetts Boston in Boston, MA. He is interested in studying the interpersonal context of clinical processes and providing alternative mental health service delivery models for reaching underserved populations. 

Dr. Lizabeth Roemer is Chair and Professor in the Department of Psychology at University of Massachusetts Boston, where she is actively involved in research and clinical training of doctoral students in clinical psychology. Dr. Roemer has published over 120 journal articles and book chapters and coauthored four books. With Dr. Susan Orsillo, Dr. Roemer has developed an acceptance-based behavioral therapy for generalized anxiety disorder. They have examined this treatment in studies funded by the National Institute of Mental Health. Their self-help book, The Mindful Way through Anxiety: Break Free from Chronic Worry and Reclaim Your Life, and self-help workbook, Worry Less, Live More: The Mindful Way Through Anxiety Workbook, draw from their decades of research in this area to provide guidance to people struggling with anxiety. 

Sarah Hayes-Skelton is an Associate Professor in the psychology department at the University of Massachusetts Boston.  She is also a licensed psychologist in Massachusetts. She completed a Ph.D. in clinical psychology from the University of Nebraska – Lincoln in 2007.  Her primary research examines the mechanisms and processes responsible for change in psychotherapy for anxiety disorders.  She is also committed to enhancing the cultural-sensitivity of these treatments.  

Amelia Yang is a first-year doctoral student in the University of Massachusetts Boston’s Clinical Psychology Program, where she is mentored by Liz Roemer. Her research interests include influences of social support on mental health symptoms and well being, and developing culturally specific and accessible treatments.

Anna Ying is currently a fourth-year doctoral student in the University of Massachusetts Boston’s Clinical Psychology Program, ​where she is mentored by Liz Roemer. Her interests include mental health disparities and access to treatment, mental health stigma in Asian Americans, and culturally sensitive treatments.

 

 

There is no doubt that many Asians are facing unfair prejudice. That's just a fact. However, the term 'Chinese Virus' does not refer to the race, but the nationality. Calling it the 'Wuhan Virus' refers to the geological area. Although, you should not use it because of the way people receive it, if someone calls it this, do not take offense. In most cases (not all!) they do not mean to offend.

Christine,
I've given your comment a lot of thought and I appreciate your willingness to be open about your thoughts. I wish to offer a challenge: It is ok for someone to be offended by use of the terms "Wuhan Virus" or "Chinese Virus" if it causes them offense. There is so much more to this article that I hope you took away than a nuanced definition of race, nationality and geography. During a time of extreme political rhetoric and an alarming rise in racism and xenophobia many people do not have the privilege of extending best intentions to someone who is using a term that perpetuates destructive stereotypes. I would argue, from my perspective, continuing to call the virus anything other than COVID or coronavirus (if those terms are something you have been exposed to) is, at best, a micro-aggression. The United States in particular has a rather bleak history with regard to treatment of Asians and Pacific Islanders (The Asia Society's Center for Global Education has a great piece on this: "Asian Americans Then and Now"). Inter-generational trauma is a very real phenomenon, and I think, especially now, this is the time to hold each other to a higher standard with regard to critical thinking, respect and compassion. We are certainly capable of it, and must confront it head on knowing not everyone will share our opinion. When it comes to passing comments I know are either incorrect or misinformed and have the potential to cause another person real harm I am challenging myself to not ignore it by assuming best intention. Instead, I am challenging myself - and perhaps you - to lean in to the discomfort and have a kind dialogue that might result in greater awareness.

I dont see any problem to mention where the current virus spread from.
This is one of the greatest global catastrophe.

This article asserts that, "East Asian individuals have been unfairly targeted for discrimination and bias partially due to the virus first being identified in Wuhan, China." The omission of the qualifier "by some people but not all" make it sound like the entire world as come against this group of individuals. That is not the case and serves to heighten, not reduce anxiety. Yes, the problem is real. But so is the fact that there are genuine and diverse allies and advocates who support these individuals. One of the first "suggestions for coping" should be: "Understand that not everyone feels this way and that a great many intelligent and deeply caring people in our society have already come to the conclusion that you are valued, co-equal, fellow-citizens. Be alert for these allies and support them, as they support you." The ongoing world-wide resistance to hated in the hearts of humans toward other humans, regardless of how/when/where hatred is manifested, is a struggle we all need to resign ourselves to, en-courage ourselves for, join together in, and bring the better angels of our nature into daily action. This is how Love replaces hate.

Advertisement